How do you win an argument with an argumentative person?

Updated: Oct 29

You don’t argue with them.
Do you know someone at work or at home who always jumps to conclusions, always has something to say and always uses their outdoor voice? The kind of person who has an opinion on everything and won’t let anyone else get a word in?
Ever tried to win an argument with them?
If it didn’t go well for you, that’s because an argumentative person has much more experience at winning arguments and they’ll beat you every time.
But if you feel like you had something important to say, you’re probably right. And if you were left feeling frustrated and disappointed, then read on my friend.
There is a way to make yourself heard.
It’s about understanding the difference between observations and conclusions, and pulling the two apart in conversation.
Most people believe that FACTS and OBSERVATIONS are the same thing. They are not.
Example: A statistic, say 15%.
Is that good? Bad? Who knows? It’s just a number.
The number is the OBSERVATION.
Now let’s say it represents the likely hood of a plane exploding in mid air. That’s not good - and that’s a FACT.
Or, lets say it represents the average annual return on an investment. That’s good - and that’s a FACT.
Can you see how facts begin to look more subjective? That’s because they are.
FACTS are conclusions formed by interpretation of OBSERVATIONS.
So, back to the problem. How to win arguments.
You’re argumentative friend is just someone who’s become very good at forming conclusions. Don’t try to make them see your conclusion, this won’t work.
If you believe someone has made the wrong conclusion, simply take them back to the observation.
You can do this with a non-threatening question like,
“Can you explain it from the beginning”?
Or,
“What’s the reason for this conclusion”?
This is how you use their superpower against them.
If you can just get them to go back a step, without feeling threatened,
and get them to slow down,
by showing interest with your questions, you’ll see them talk their own way around to the logical conclusion you’ve been trying to make them see.
The catch is, they take all the credit.
The good news is, they do all the work.
Like a skilful matador, you kill the argument while the bull does all the huffing and puffing.
Questions are the device you use. Guide the conversation with non threatening questions.
OBSERVATION is the battle field you take them to. Back to the place where conclusions haven’t been formed yet. Keep it objective so nobody’s feelings are hurt.
Then let them explain their way back to the FACTS (conclusion).


Comments