Can you scare someone into taking something seriously?

Updated: Oct 29

A colleague of mine told me a story this week. On his second day of work he was shouted at by the manager.
"Don't drag that!"
He admitted to me that he still hears that voice in his head sometimes. It came up because we were shifting old, depleted batteries to their final resting place. They're very heavy so I encouraged him to save his back and just drag them.
So I asked him, "What was it you weren't supposed to drag?"
He can't remember.
Now isn't that a useless lesson? It must have been important at the time. But because his manager shouted at him aggressively and never bothered to explain, that's all he remembers - being shouted at!
Pavlov's experiments with his dogs are well documented; a conditioned response can be trained into someone with a reward. What's not well documented (because it was never part of the controlled experiments) is that Pavlov and his assistants noticed a change in the dogs' behaviour after a traumatic experience. The basement where the dogs were caged suffered a serious flood and the dogs had to be quickly evacuated. Pavlov's assistants saved the dogs by coercing them to swim for it.
Afterwards, some accounts say that the dogs were not the same. In some dogs, all conditioned reflexes were absent and they would not touch the food at all.
What this tells us is that fear undoes learning, and it's being confirmed by many other studies in neuroscience and psychiatry.
But wait a minute! Managers, captains, officers, how many times have you wanted to throttle someone because they just aren't getting it?! How many times have you threatened someone with some horrible act of violence because they caused a near miss - again?!
I'll admit it, I have.
It's what we do when we're stressed. It's why mothers threaten their kids, and even throw insults at them.
But isn't that useless? Fear undoes learning. We know this. We've evolved.
Learning requires an agile, open mind — one that’s curious and unafraid. People retain the most when they’re relaxed, at ease, and hungry for more.
How do you inspire your learners to engage, explore, and pull knowledge towards them?
What’s your best practice for creating the right environment for learning?


Comments